Vague ‘stirring up hatred’ offences in the Scottish Government’s Hate Crime Bill threaten free speech, including evangelism and Christian comment on sexual ethics. The plans have triggered a huge public backlash.
References
- 1 The Herald online, 30 September 2020, see https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/18759081.john-cleese-speaks-disastrous-scots-hate-crime-bill/ as at 14 October 2020
- 2 The Times online, 12 August 2020, see https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/rowan-atkinson-fights-hate-crime-bill-r8c3tfz0w as at 14 October 2020
- 3 Savanta ComRes Free to Disagree Scotland poll, 6-13 August 2020, Q1, see https://comresglobal.com/polls/free-to-disagree-free-speech-poll-august-2020/ as at 14 October 2020
- 4 The Herald online, 23 September 2020, see https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/18742331.snp-announce-hate-crime-bill-climbdown-free-speech-row/ as at 14 October 2020
- 5 ‘Faculty welcomes amendment to Hate Crime Bill’, Faculty of Advocates, 23 September 2020, see http://www.advocates.org.uk/news-and-responses/news/2020/sep/faculty-welcomes-amendment-to-hate-crime-bill as at 14 October 2020
- 6 ‘SoE welcomes Scottish Hate Crime Bill climbdown but reiterates threat to free speech’, Society of Editors, 24 September 2020, see https://www.societyofeditors.org/soe_news/soe-welcomes-scottish-hate-crime-bill-climbdown-but-reiterates-threat-to-free-speech/ as at 14 October 2020
- 7 Savanta ComRes, Free to Disagree Scotland poll, 6-13 August 2020, Q3, see https://comresglobal.com/polls/free-to-disagree-free-speech-poll-august-2020/ as at 14 October 2020
- 8 ‘Press Release 16/07/2020’, Free to Disagree, 16 July 2020, see https://freetodisagree.scot/press_releases/press-release-16-07-2020/ as at 14 October 2020
- 9 ‘Lack of clarity in Hate Crime Bill could threaten freedom of expression’, Law Society of Scotland, 27 July 2020, see https://www.lawscot.org.uk/news-and-events/law-society-news/hatecrimebill/ as at 14 October 2020
- 10 Savanta ComRes, Free to Disagree Scotland poll, 6-13 August 2020, Q1, see https://comresglobal.com/polls/free-to-disagree-free-speech-poll-august-2020/ as at 14 October 2020
- 11 Telegraph online, 5 September 2020, see https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2020/07/29/scotlands-catholic-bishops-warn-bible-could-fall-foul-snp-hate/ as at 14 October 2020
- 12 ‘Yousaf can’t “magic away” J.K. Rowling hate crime concerns’, Free to Disagree, see https://freetodisagree.scot/press_releases/yousaf-cant-magic-away-j-k-rowling-hate-crime-concerns/ as at 14 October 2020
- 13 ‘SNP must back further changes to hate crime bill – Jim Sillars’, Free to Disagree, 28 September 2020, see https://freetodisagree.scot/snp-must-back-further-changes-to-hate-crime-bill-jim-sillars/ as at 14 October 2020
- 14 Scottish Daily Mail, 24 September 2020
- 15 ‘SoE welcomes Scottish Hate Crime Bill climbdown but reiterates threat to free speech’, Society of Editors, 24 September 2020, see https://www.societyofeditors.org/soe_news/soe-welcomes-scottish-hate-crime-bill-climbdown-but-reiterates-threat-to-free-speech/ as at 14 October 2020
- 16 ‘Plan to amend Scottish hate crime bill isn’t enough, says NSS’, National Secular Society, 23 September 2020, see https://www.secularism.org.uk/news/2020/09/plan-to-amend-scottish-hate-crime-bill-isnt-enough-says-nss as at 14 October 2020
- 17 ‘The SNP’s hate crime u-turn isn’t enough’, The Spectator, 23 September 2020, see https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-snp-s-hate-crime-u-turn-isn-t-enough as at 14 October 2020
- 18 Telegraph online, 29 July 2020, see https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2020/09/05/bbc-senior-judges-sheriffs-police-warn-snps-hate-crime-bill/ as at 14 October 2020
- 19 ‘Lack of clarity in Hate Crime Bill could threaten freedom of expression’, Law Society of Scotland, 27 July 2020, see https://www.lawscot.org.uk/news-and-events/law-society-news/hatecrimebill/ as at 14 October 2020
- 20 Mail Online, 24 July 2020, see https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8556175/New-vague-Scots-hate-crime-law-stifle-free-speech.html as at 14 October 2020